What games would you rebuy from zero?

There was a thread cross posted to the 1 Player and Minimalist Gamers guilds on BGG recently that asked the question: What games would you rebuy from zero? It came from the user’s current troubles with a moving company losing most of their games. Missing their games, it sparked the question and they came to a surprisingly short list. This person only has 24 games according to their profile so rebuying just 7 of them back is still a decent percentage of the missing collection.

My collection is currently over 8 times larger at 204 at the time of this post, with 56 of those on my for trade/sale list. So that leaves me at 148 games that I’ve decided to keep for now. Using approximately the same percentage of games, I’d be able to keep about 36 games. That’s still a solid board game collection size, but even at that number I think I would miss some. I’ve pored over my list and come up with the games I would immediately rebuy. I was surprised at what I actually had to have, and like many of the thread’s respondents, wonder if I should move closer to that number.

Before we get to the rebuy list, I’m going to spoil it some by mentioning some games I immediately expected to keep but opted not to and the reason why.

Just Missing The Cut

Star Realms – My reigning favorite game should have a been a lock for this list, but I’ve never even played my physical copy after all these years. All my plays are on the app and because I have access to the app, I don’t need to have a copy. Plus, I don’t play a ton of two player only games in person or know many people who might be interested in playing often.

Biblios – A title that has made every Top 10 (or 5x3) list that I’ve done. I really love this game, but it’s never been nearly as well received with anyone else that I’ve ever played it with. Without a solo variant and this version being out of print, there’s no way to justify immediately replacing it.

Scythe – Another long-time member of my Top 10 (or 5x3) lists slipped a little recently but it’s still the one “big game” in my collection. Problem is it never gets played. It’s bulky and a little rules heavy to try and bring to my board game meetups, since I don’t know who will be there each time. I played 10 solo games back in December of 2023 for the Deep Dive December Challenge, but it hasn’t seen the table since. The cost for a new copy  (~$100) is way too high for a game that doesn’t see the table often.

KLASK & KLASK 4 – I love KLASK and wrote a very detailed post about acquiring my first copy…yes first because I actually have two now thanks to Goodwill. I also love KLASK 4, probably even more than the original, but the cost of each is more than I’d be willing to spend to immediately replace them at ~$70 and ~$110 respectively.

So what games would I immediately go out and buy to start my new collection?

My New Collection From Zero

6 nimmt! - One of my most played games of all time and the only game on this list that could play up to 10 players, although it's really at its best around 5-7. Easy for casual and non-gamers to pick up quickly and still fun for more serious hobby gamers.

Azul - One of the most well known abstract and family games on the market. It's a beautiful game with nice components, is easy to teach, and can be played differently depending on the group. Want to be nice and just focus on your board? Go for it. Want to hate draft tiles just to screw with your opponents? Even better.

Blokus - I think this is the only game you'll find amongst the mass market games. It's one of the games that really got me into the hobby and holds so many memories of those early times. Like Azul, it's puzzly and can be played somewhat nicely, or in this case, even more incredibly meanly. There's nothing like just completely cutting one color off early as a way to set yourself up for victory.

Calico - Probably one of the last ones to make the list is another puzzly one (I'm sensing a pattern here) that's easy to teach but a little more complex than those previously listed. It's a visually pleasing game that really pushes your brain and has cats which is a welcomed theme at most tables.

Can’t Stop - My second most played game of all time is this press your luck dice rolling game, that once again is easy to teach and is enjoyed by all types of gamers. I have the Korean L-Board edition where the box folds out into the board and the components nestle inside it when closed. 

Carcassonne - This was one of the games that really pushed my love for the hobby to the next level. While its complexity falls in line with everything listed so far, it feels like there's more to focus on, especially once any expansions are added. I've made a point many times on this blog that I think Carcassonne with the first two expansions is the closest thing to a perfectly designed game as you can find.

Cascadia - I wrote a whole post about Cascadia back in 2021 highlighting how amazing it is. It went on to win the 2022 Spiel des Jahres and has had a bunch of spinoffs that are part of my current collection. The original remains my favorite but the whole "universe" is really enjoyable.

Castle Combo - I love this game and said so when I highlighted it in November 2025 Wrap-Up post. It also crashed into the top 3 of My Top 5 Board Games (x3) Part Deux card games list. I enjoy the gameplay so much, I bought it just so it qualified before the post when live. AND it was my #1 New to Me Game of 2025.

The Castles of Burgundy - CoB is THE classic Euro game and mainstay on my Top 10 Board Games lists. There's a reason why it still remains in the top 20 of all games on BoardGameGeek after all this time. It's elegant, not flashy, and just does so much right. This is the most complex game on the list at just under 3.0 on the weight scale but there are a couple more to come.

Five Tribes: The Djinns of Naqala - Another top 100 game on BGG, Five Tribes came back into my life in 2024 after a 7 year hiatus from my first and only play. It uses a mancala mechanic of dropping meeples across tiles that I just adore. Throw in a handful of other mechanics and one of the best table presences around and you've got a real winner.

Flip 7 - An entry from my Top 10 New to Me Games of 2025 list, Flip 7 probably wouldn't crack my top 5 favorite card games but it's right up there for the same reasons a lot of games on this list made it. It's a press your luck card game that's great to play as a warm up or squeeze in at the end of a gaming session. Like Can't Stop, the gameplay allows any age gamer to be successful, which makes it very kid friendly. I included it because it has a low complexity (lowest on the list too), ability to accommodate up to 8 players, and it's just a fun time.

The Game - I don't really know why this game is on here but as I went through the Excel pull of my collection from BGG, it was an immediate keep. The thing is, I really don't like the multiplayer or "regular" version of the game. For those who know me, co-ops aren't really my thing usually and this one definitely didn't do it for me. HOWEVER, I love the solo variant of this game. It reminds me of the game Solitaire that you play with a standard deck of cards and is/was a default game on all Windows computers. It's relaxing and feels so rewarding if you not only "win" but also are able to play every card.

The Guild of Merchant Explorers - I've covered this multiples times on the blog from the October 2023 Wrap-Up, to the Top 10 New to Me Games of 2023, and most recently in my My Top 5 Board Games (x3) Part Deux under the light games category. Multiple maps, asymmetric card powers, and a race to objectives has made it my 5th most played game of all time in just a few short years.

L.L.A.M.A. - Love it or hate it but this is game is what UNO aspires to be. There's a lot of luck but there are some strategies and decisions that are crucial to being successful. It's the lowest ranked game from this list on BGG, sitting currently just inside the top 2000. However, it was a 2019 Spiel des Jahres Nominee so that's good enough for me.

No Thanks! - Another simple card game that has been on many of my lists. Each turn offers two options, take the card or play a chip to say No Thanks! It's that decision that isn't always as simple as it seems. It can be agonizing as your pile slowly depletes as you try to not take a high valued card.

Rajas of the Ganges - The top heavy game from My Top 5 Board Games (x3) Part Deux is a must have for players who like Euro games. It's a got a unique theme and an end game trigger that can be anxiety inducing in the best way. Like any good euro, it's got a bunch of ways to score and makes it so you always have multiple interesting decisions to make on each turn.

Rebirth - My #2 New to Me Game of 2025 is a newer designer from the famed Reiner Knizia. It hooked my right away from the first play and I picked up my own copy shortly after because of it. Like Carcassonne, you draw a tile and play it, but it's where you place the tile and the actions that come from that placement that makes the game shine. You're constantly competing for space as the board fills up and need to keep your personal objectives in mind along the way.

SCOUT - As if this list needed another "cards with numbers" game, SCOUT has become a group favorite that I keep in my bag for public meetups. It combines a unique starting hand decision with card shedding that made it to the top of my Top 10 New to Me Games Of 2024 list.

Survive The Island - For the first time, I'm listing this reimplementation of a longtime favorite, Survive: Escape from Atlantis!, instead of the original. As I wrote in the June 2025 Wrap-Up, this is more of a reworked version because it shares the same theme and most of the gameplay is identical. The updates to the monsters and rules offer a cleaner game with updated art. It's the most directly mean game (the word cutthroat game is in the description) on this list but it's all part of the fun as you try to save your adventurers. 

Sushi Go Party! - I needed a drafting game and as stated in the 10 Games Exercise, I like this more than 7 Wonders even though I'd argue that the latter is the better game but also more than double the price. My mind quickly went to Sushi Go! as a lock but for a few dollars more, why not get the more deluxe version that can play the original cards and so much more?

What Did I Learn?

When I first started writing this, I hadn’t considered cost as much but that did end up becoming a major decider on whether I’d bring a game back into my collection right away. As you can see there are a bunch of smaller and less expensive games that offer a lot of bang for your buck. At the time of this writing, my theoretical new starting collection would cost ~$550 from online retailers. I also only replaced 20 games which less than 15% of my total not for trade/sale collection and think what’s listed is a really solid variety of games. 

I really enjoy exercises like these and wasn't surprised that a handful of the games that made this list were also on the $100 Board Game Collection Challenge and 10 Games Exercise lists as well. Hopefully I’m never put in a situation where I’d have to do this but I think this exercise really helped my focus on what games I truly enjoy. That’s not to say I wouldn’t miss many of those who didn’t make the list.

What games would you rebuy from zero? Please share in the comments.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Lay's Stax are better than Pringles

Age of Origins

Game Design Bug